CFD Review  
Serving the CFD Community with News, Articles, and Discussion
 
CFD Review

User Preferences
Site Sponsorship
Headline Feeds
Mobile Edition
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
twitter

Submit a CFD Story

Site Sponsors
CD-adapco
Pointwise: Reliable CFD meshing
ANSYS

Tell a Friend
Help this site to grow by sending a friend an invitation to visit this site.

CFD News by Email
Did you know that you can get today's CFD Review headlines mailed to your inbox? Just log in and select Email Headlines Each Night on your User Preferences page.

 
Accuracy, Convergence and Mesh Quality
Posted Tue May 22, 2012 @08:41AM
Print version Email story Tweet story
News “We know embarrassingly little about how the mesh affects the CFD solution,” said Prof. Carl Ollivier-Gooch of the University of British Columbia.

That sounds like a poor way to describe the state of affairs in CFD research, but most in attendance at the Mesh Quality/Resolution, Practice, Current Research, and Future Directions Workshop held last summer in Dayton, OH would agree.


Sponsor CFD Review

Dr. Ollivier-Gooch's statement is counter to what we all know to be true in practice, that a good mesh helps the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) solver converge to the correct answer while minimizing the computer resources expended. Stated differently, most every decent solver will yield an accurate answer with a good mesh, but it takes the most robust of solvers to get an answer on a bad mesh.

The crux of the issue is what precisely is meant by “a good mesh.” Syracuse University's Prof. John Dannenhoffer points out that we are much better at identifying a bad mesh than we are at judging a good one. Distinguishing good from bad is clouded by the fact that badness is a black-white determination of whether the mesh will run or not. (Badness often only means whether there are any negative volume cells.) On the other hand, goodness is all shades of gray – there are good meshes and there are better meshes.

Go on to read the rest of Pointwise's excellent summary of the Mesh Quality Workshop.

[ Post Comment ]

CD adapco Academic Simulation Image Contest | Speakers Announced for the 12th FLOW-3D European Users Conference  >

 

 
CFD Review Login
User name:

Password:

Create an Account

Related Links
  • excellent summary
  • Pointwise
  • More on News
  • 'Accuracy, Convergence and Mesh Quality' | Login/Create an Account | Search Discussion

    The following comments are owned by whoever posted them.
    We are not responsible for them in any way.

    To be is to be related. -- C.J. Keyser. All content except comments
    ©2014, Viable Computing.

    [ home | submit story | search | polls | faq | preferences | privacy | terms of service | rss  ]